No Free Lunch
By George Hickox

Click here for the pdf of this page


Go to the previous page

 Go to the next page

Go to the table of contents page

Go to the back issues page

No Free Lunch
By George Hickox

No Free Lunch
By George Hickox
One of the iron rules of dog training is: Make sure the dog knows why he's being corrected or rewarded. Dogs learn by association, and they will associate a correction with what happened just before the correction and/or at the place the correction occurred. Therefore, if the dog did not know why he was corrected, he may associate the negative with something the trainer did not intend.
For example, if the dog were corrected where a bird had been planted but did not know why the hammer fell, he might think that bad things happen wherever there's bird scent. He has a way of solving that problem for himself - blinking. The dog purposely avoids the bird for fear of getting in trouble. A dog that becomes apprehensive from not knowing why he gets in trouble is very difficult to advance to higher levels of learning.
The other side of that is that the dog should not be rewarded if he does not understand why. Breaking this rule of dog training is as equally detrimental to advancing a dog to A+ standards as is indiscriminate correction.
Here's why. The dog is a pack animal, and he's constantly checking for weaknesses in the pack leader. Rewarding with treats or praising for no reason sends a message to the dog that he has a vote and that commands are an option. But dog training is not a democracy; the trainer holds all the votes.
Further, if the dog learns that he gets rewarded for no reason at all, he quickly perceives that he does not have to try - he will get a paycheck whether he goes to work or not. There becomes no accountability or responsibility. A dog that gets paid for no effort is being reinforced for not trying. Not good!
Rewards are a big motivator. We want a program of incentives, so when the dog gives us an effort or desired behavior, we should reinforce it - only giving the dog his dinner after he sits, for example. By developing a program of only rewarding the dog for trying to give us something, we will develop a dog with an open mind for learning. A dog who tries to succeed is a pleasure to train.
The best time to instill a work ethic in the dog is during puppyhood. This is the period of time when the dog is learning what works for him. It is easier to imprint younger dogs than it is to correct learned behavior in older dogs. That said, a program of reinforcements for giving an effort is the prescription for rehabilitating any dog. Give me something, and I'll give you something.


 Go to our home page

Subscribe to BD&RN 

Advertising Rates 

 Advertise with us

 Send us a message



 American Water Spaniels




 Boxes & Trailers




Chesapeake Bay Retrievers 



Cocker Spaniels 

Curly Coat Retrievers 


Dog Food


 English Setters

English Springer Spaniels 

 French Brittanys

 Flat Coat Retrievers

 German Shorthaired Pointers

 German Wirehaired Pointers

Golden Retrievers

 Gordon Setters

Guns & Gunsmithing 

 Gun Shows

 Hunts & Training Areas

 Irish/Red Setters

 Irish Water Spaniels

Labrador Retrievers 

 Large Munsterlanders 

Llewellin Setters 


 Perdiguero De Burgos


Pointing Labs



 Rare Breeds

Real Estate







WP Griffons

Go to Canine

 Go to

Go to 

 Cool Places on the web

 Go to Hunter

Power State pages

 Power Breed pages

 Power Back issue pages

 Power Board pages

 Power Misc pages

Copyrights Bird Dog & Retriever News May 2018
Do not reproduce or retransmit in any form, and we surf the web, we'll find you.
Maintained by Dennis Guldan e-mail
Bird Dog & Retriever News, PO Box 120089, New Brighton, MN 55112,
Phone 612-868-9169 Adv deadline 1st of the month prior to the issue.